Energy Transition Conference 2019
Energy Transition Conference 2019

Changing the energy system to build a sustainable society
26 March at Clarion Hotel & Congress, Trondheim
We know that we need to keep the global temperature rise well below 2 degrees above pre-industrial levels, but how do we change the energy system to support transition to a sustainable society?
What role will the energy system play in the transition of the rest of society?
How can the different energy technologies work together in a new low carbon energy system?
What are the missing pieces of the puzzle – in technology, regulations and business models?
And how can we as citizens take part in the transformation of society?
The main focus of the conference is the role of the energy system in transition towards a sustainable society while continuing to be a driver for economic growth. European and international cooperation will be central to the conference. The conference is a blend of keynotes, panel debates and plenary discussions, and participants will be international experts from academia, industry, government and NGOs.
Conference 2019
![]() State Secretary, Ministry of Petroleum and Energy |
![]() Moderator of the Energy Transition Conference |
![]() CEO & President SINTEF |
![]() Rector NTNU |
![]() Senior Program Officer IRENA |
![]() General Manager Global CCS Institute |
![]() SVP New Energy Solutions Equinor |
![]() SVP and Head of Corporate Strategy Statkraft |
![]() Researcher NTNU |
![]() Chief Scientist JGCRI |
![]() CEO PSR Brazil |
![]() DIrector NTNU Energy |
![]() Senior Combustion Expert Siemens |
![]() Professor and Director of CenSES, NTNU |
![]() President Gaffney, Cline & Associates |
![]() Chairman eSmartSystems |
![]() Research Team Leader VTT Research Centre |
![]() Chair of the Board ENTSO-E |
![]() Vice President SINTEF Industry |
![]() Researcher Tyndall Centre for Climate Research |
![]() Manager Business Development Equinor |
![]() Professor in Psychology NTNU |
0800: Registration
0900: Welcome by Johan Hustad
0915: Chat with Gunnar Bovim and Alexandra Bech Gjørv
What is the role of major universities and research institutions?
0930: Transition of the Integrated Energy System
Liv Lønnum - Norwegian Ministry of Petroleum and Energy
Asgeir Tomasgard - NTNU
Luiz Barroso - PSR
Guloren Turan - Global CCS Institute
Stephen Bull - Equinor
Henrik Sætness - Statkraft
Panel Discussion: Liv Lønnum, Guloren Turan, Asgeir Tomasgard, Stephen Bull and Henrik Sætness
1130: Lunch
1230: Chat with Jae Edmonds and Helene Muri
The big picture - from ambition to action - what do we need to do?
1300: Well Below 2 Degrees - From Ambition to Action - Changing How We Live
Charlie Wilson - Tyndall Climate Research Centre
Asami Miketa - IRENA
Tiina Koljonen - VTT Research Centre
Christian Klöckner - NTNU
Bente Hagem - ENTSO-E
Panel Discussion: Charlie WIlson, Asami Miketa, Tiina Koljonen, Christian Klöckner, Bente Hagem and Atsushi Kurosawa (Institute of Applied Energy)
1430: Break
1500: New Technologies, Solutions, Gaps and Needs - The Transformation of Society
Henrik Solgaard Andersen - Equinor
Jenny Larfeldt - Siemens
Nathan Meehan - Gaffney, Cline & Associates
Jørgen Kildahl - eSmartSystems
Eli Aamot - SINTEF
Panel Discussion: Henrik Solgaard Andersen, Jenny Larfeldt, Nathan Meehan, Frank O'Sullivan, Jørgen Kildahl and Eli Aamot
1650: Conclusion
1700: End of today
--------------------------
1900: Reception
1930: Conference Dinner
Transition of the Integrated Energy System
The transition toward a low carbon energy system require fundamental changes to many elements in the total energy chain. Key factors in the transition are renewables, distributed energy generation, storage technologies, digitalization and active market participation by the consumer side. Some central topics and questions for this theme are:
- Integration of heat and electricity
- Integration across sectors like waste, heat, power, industry and transport
- Market incentives for short-term allocations and long-term investments
- Pricing of energy versus pricing of flexibility
- Digitalization and new business models
Well Below 2 Degrees – From Ambition to Action
This theme addresses the strategies needed to meet the objectives of the Paris agreement discussing the current status and what will be needed in terms of increased efforts: policies, technologies, behavior, and transformation of society. The theme will have a special focus on how to deal with uncertainty: climate risk, financial risk and policy risk.
- How does industry make investments under uncertainty?
- How does political uncertainty affect the choices made by the industry?
- How can policy makers reduce this uncertainty?
- Are there financial barriers preventing capital to be spent on the transition?
- What is needed to increase international cooperation?
The session will address how society can close the gap between the actions that the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) and climate researchers say are necessary, and the goals of political climate plans and the nationally determined contributions (NDCs) of the Paris Agreement.
New Technologies, Solutions, Gaps and Needs – The Transformation of Society
This theme will focus on technological solutions that we are implementing or demonstrating today and which solutions we do not currently have, but that we need to develop. In addition, the session will address the transformation of society focusing on the role of citizens in the energy transition.
- How can technologies drive new economic growth while driving towards a zero emission society?
- What are the possibilities and barriers in this transition, and how can we stimulate accelerated transition?
- How can we stimulate new businesses and investments in new opportunities?
- Are there “Magic technologies” – what are realistic technologies?
- How will we live our lives in the future, and what are the major changes of lifestyle that will come?
- How do we travel in the future, what kind of buildings do we live in, and what do we eat?
- What is the approach of developing countries to the transition?
The session will address how we can utilize available technologies as a first step toward a zero emission society and how we can use this for development of the next steps. The session will also address how these technological changes may change how we live our lives in the next decades. Will technology drive change in society, or will society drive change in technology?
The International advisory board for the Energy Transition Initiative:
- Jae Edmonds, University of Maryland/JGCRI,
- Nick Eyre, Oxford University,
- Carolyn Fischer, Resources for the Future,
- Richard Green, Imperial college,
- Christian von Hirschhausen, TU Berlin,
- Franziska Holz, DIW Berlin,
- Steven Gabriel, University of Maryland and NTNU,
- Volker Krey, IIASA,
- Mark O´Malley, NREL,
- Reinhard Madlener RWTH Aachen,
- David Newbury, Cambridge University,
- Sergey Paltsev, MIT,
- Michael Pollit, Cambridge University,
- Frank O´Sullivan, MIT.
Programme committee
- Asgeir Tomasgard, NTNU (chair)
- Johan Hustad, NTNU
- Fride Vullum-Bruer, NTNU
- Tomas Moe Skjølsvold, NTNU
- Erica Lösftröm, NTNU
- Hege Jørgensen Tunstad, NTNU
- Ottar Skagen, Equinor
- Hege Rognø, Equinor
- Per Ivar Karstad, Equinor
- Tor Ulleberg, Equinor
- Ragne Hildrum, Statkraft
- Audun Rosland, Miljødirektoratet
- Stig Ødegaard Ottesen, eSmartSystems
- Beate Nossum, Footprint
- Snorre Valen, Technoport
Opening with Johan Hustad
Chat with Gunnar Bovim and Alexandra Bech Gjørv
What is the role of major universities and research institutions?
Session 1 - Transition of the Integrated Energy System
Liv Lønnum - Norwegian Ministry of Petroleum and Energy
Norway’s role in the energy transition
Asgeir Tomasgard – NTNU
Towards a zero emission European power system
Luiz Barroso – PSR
Transition of the integrated (decarbonized) energy system: The Brazilian experience
Guloren Turan - Global CCS Institute
Carbon Capture & Storage in the energy transition
Stephen Bull – Equinor
Equinor and the energy transition
Henrik Sætness – Statkraft
The energy system of the future
Panel Discussion Session 1
Chat with Jae Edmonds and Helene Muri
Jae Edmonds – JGCRI
Why implementing Paris is so hard and so important
Helene Muri – NTNU
What does the IPCC tell us?
Session 2: Well Below 2 Degrees - From Ambition to Action
Charlie Wilson - Tyndall Climate Research Centre
Transforming energy services to limit global warming to 1.5°C
Asami Miketa – IRENA
Renewables in the clean energy transition
Tiina Koljonen - VTT Research Centre
Moving beyond energy in energy transition – case examples from global and Finnish perspectives
Christian Klöckner – NTNU
Engaging citizens – from knowledge to action
Bente Hagem - ENTSO-E
Well below 2 degrees – The TSOs contribution
Panel Discussion Session 2
Session 3: New Technologies, Solutions, Gaps and Needs - The Transformation of Society
Henrik Solgaard Andersen – Equinor
Decarbonisation of natural gas
Jenny Larfeldt – Siemens
Hydrogen firing in flexible industrial gas turbines
Nathan Meehan - Gaffney, Cline & Associates
BHGE energy transition strategy – How to reach net-zero?
Jørgen Kildahl – eSmartSystems
“AI unlocks the door to a sustainable society, - culture allows us to open it”
Eli Aamot – SINTEF
Energy Transition – new technologies and new solutions
Panel Discussion Session 3
Workshops 2019
2 March:
The current electricity market design in Europe might not be ideal for the future carbon lean system. New developments in the electricity sector will be driven by the need for environmental and climate sustainability, technological developments in efficient generation technologies, and innovations at the system integration level. This workshop will focus on economic mechanisms to incentivize investment in systems and technologies that aim to lower energy costs, improve security of supply, and lower carbon emissions. The workshop topic will be a selection of (but not limited to) the following:
- Market design for electricity systems dominated by renewable generation sources.
- Incentives for trading off investment in storage, transmission and distribution network, generation, and demand management.
- The role of hydropower in this context.
Confirmed speakers:
Hans Auer (TU Vienna), Luiz Barroso (PSR Brazil), Peter Bauhofer (TIWAG), Mette Bjørndal (NHH), Ole Gunnar Dahlhaug (NTNU), Annelies Delnooz (Vito), Gerard Doorman (Statnett), Joachim Geske (Imperial College), Bente Hagem (ENTSOE), Atle Harby (Sintef), Danny Ralph (Cambridge University), Christian Skar (Powel/NTNU), Daniel Stølsbotn (Nord Pool/NODES), Berit Tennbakk (Thema), Caroline Østlie (Statkraft).
Date: 25 March
Time: 0900-1600
Registration: Press here
Place: Quality Hotel Augustin, Kongensgate 26, 7011 Trondheim
Contact: Håvard Tangvik
25 March:
Welcome to a 4-hour student workshop at NTNU, where we work on topics related to Smart Cities – how can we re-think the way we live in cities to stimulate the energy transition?
We will work on how we can involve citizens in using the city in new ways, and that the citizens themselves can be active participants in the future energy system. The workshop will start with getting a general background on how we could stimulate citizen participation and interactions, to could help create new ways of tackling energy use, pollution, transportation and energy efficiency in the cities. Then, we go into concrete issues where cities, citizens and industry could work and interact smarter in the future – and generate ideas that could be parts of the solution.
- How should cities tackle transport in the future, with fewer cars and more use of public transport?
- How can cities reduce their demand for energy or use energy in a smarter way?
- How could we reduce the amount of air pollution or waste in our cities?
This student workshop is in the lead-up to the Energy Transition conference 2019, where you can meet and discuss with other students that share your interest in the future of energy, through team-based idea generation.
Date: 25 March
Time: 1200-1600
Registration: Press here
Place: Fram Innovasjonssenter, 3. etg Gamle Fysikk, Gløshaugen, 7034 Trondheim
Contact: Håvard Tangvik
27 March:
In this workshop, selected results of five ongoing EU projects are presented which focus on the role of citizens in the energy transition (as consumers but also in other roles as citizens). A common theme in all projects is exploring the roles citizens take in relation to energy use and transition of energy systems, adoption of new technologies, de-centralized production of energy, etc. They also focus on the impact the energy transition has on individuals, social groups and societies and the complex interaction between the energy transition and other societal developments. The projects utilize a large variety of methods from the social science spectrum and are characterized by active stakeholder involvement. The workshop includes an activating participatory session in the end, integrating the project results with the workshop participants’ understandings.
Confirmed speakers:
Ines Campos (University of Lisbon), Audley Genus (Kingston University London), Christian Klöckner (NTNU), Erica Löfström (NTNU), Giuseppe Pellegrini Masini (NTNU), Karina Standal (CICERO)
Date: 27 March
Time: 1000-1500
Registration: Press here
Place: Quality Hotel Augustin, Kongensgate 26, 7011 Trondheim
Contact: Håvard Tangvik
28 March:
Transportation stands out as a key sector when striving to decarbonize our societies. In this workshop, we will explore key issues within research on transport towards 2050, seeking to enlighten where current research is leading us, what is missing and what should be our future agenda of inquiry. A special focus will be given to the role of new technologies in transforming modes of mobility and practices of transport. Digitalization, electrification, sharing and automation are three trends that are considered important. Rather than consider these technologies as unambiguously representing progress, this workshop will investigate them as elements that can be part of transforming societies, and life on future roads.
Such technologies might entail substantial benefits to society, but history also illustrates that new technologies often bring unforeseen social consequences. Are for instance autonomous vehicles a way of extending a non-sustainable car-based society, or will they herald a society with far fewer vehicles that are mostly shared? Will such technology democratize mobility, providing universal and instant access, or will they mainly work in highly gentrified areas, reinforcing patterns of social stratification in access to transport? Will big data from millions of vehicles primarily be used to help optimize transportation patterns and increase road safety, or will we see the emergence of new information ecologies, which will largely serve the interest of tech-giant corporations?
The answers to such questions are highly contingent on contemporary practices of innovation, planning and technology development, and the degree to which such processes reflexively engage with societal questions. Further, they depend on perceived public needs and aspirations produced in contemporary mobility culture, and the many practices that today leads people to drive, cycle, walk, and take the bus and train, and which leads companies to transport goods in the ways that they do. Hence, this workshop featuring international and national transport, mobility and innovations studies renowned scholars, will combine a future oriented gaze on expectations and imaginaries, with a contemporary focus on activities that either re-enforces or destabilizes how we as societies are mobile.
This workshop is hosted by the DRIVERS-project, funded by the Norwegian Research Councils program Transport 2025. See www.driversproject.org for more
Confirmed speakers:
Debbie Hopkins (Oxford University), Dimitri Milakis (DLR), Milos Mladenovic (Aalto University), Jack Stilgoe (UCL).
Date: 28 March
Time: 0900-1600
Registration: Press here
Place: Quality Hotel Augustin, Kongensgate 26, 7011 Trondheim
Contact: Håvard Tangvik
28 March:
The energy system plays a central role in the transition to a low emission society. As variable renewable energy solutions enter a path of sustained growth in electricity, key energy transition challenges shift towards integrating large shares of renewables through additional flexibility and by decarbonizing other key emitting sectors, such as buildings, transport and industry. In this situation, energy system integration plays a major role, both in terms of integration of different energy vectors and in the sector coupling.
The goal of the workshop is to address both current research challenges and the policy dimension. In particular, we want to get an idea of which areas are most critical to focus on, concerning research, but also concerning policy development and how to best influence future climate politics. This workshop aims to identify the main research challenges for the energy system. It will do so by addressing different futures and for each of these by investigating some of the key questions:
- Technology choice and related infrastructures. Technology choice and focus on different energy carriers affects challenges for energy production, storage, infrastructure and value chain design.
- The consumer is at the center of the future energy system, taking a more active role by making the demand side more flexible. What is the potential role and how does human choice affect the different technologies?
- Market design plays a key role incentivizing both short-term resource allocation and investments.
- Policy support and instruments: How does policy support play together with markets and decision makers to promote the technologies needed?
The workshop will address three different futures, electrification, hydrogen, decentralization, focusing on the questions above:
- Electrification
- The hydrogen society
- Fully decentralized system
Finally, the workshop will attempt to identify the main challenges to address in redesigning the energy system, focusing on how the energy system will play a role in low emission industry, transport and in the building sector. The end result will be a short policy brief with clear advice on which research is needed, and potentially which areas are the most critical, and which incentives should be prioritized in order to reach the climate goals set by Norway, by EU and by the UN.
Confirmed speakers:
Lars Bonderup Bjørn (EWII), Franziska Holz (DIW Berlin), Magnus Korpås (NTNU), Atsushi Kurosawa (IAE), Trieu Mai (NREL), Eirik Byklum (Equinor), Petter Nekså (Sintef), Lasse Torgersen (Hydro), Øystein Ulleberg (IFE), Knut Vrålstad (Statkraft).
Date: 28 March
Time: 1000-1700
Registration: Press here
Place: Quality Hotel Augustin, Kongensgate 26, 7011 Trondheim
Contact: Håvard Tangvik
29 March:
In the 2015 Paris Agreement, world leaders pledged to cut greenhouse gas emissions radically. This workshop addresses how fundamental change can be implemented in manufacturing and process industries focusing on metal production, fertilizer production, cement and refineries.
The fundamental question asked is: How can the transition be accelerated in these sectors in order to achieve sufficient emission reductions in 2030 and close to zero emissions in 2050. The objective of the workshop is to facilitate a discussion involving academia, industry and government, resulting in a policy brief addressing this topic. Some of the question to answer are:
- What are the main research challenges that needs to be solved related to technologies and solutions
- What type of sector couplings are needed, for example to the energy sector?
- Related to the above, what are the needed policy instruments in the medium and in the long term needed to support the transition of industry?
The workshop will be organized in 4 sessions each of them consisting of two presentations aiming to give an overview of an essential part of the state-of-the art, two-three prepared interventions presenting insights from different perspectives as well as 45-minute discussion part. The detailed program is in development, but the following topics will be included.
- Technology challenges and solutions: The transition of industries will require emission reductions in mechanical work, in process heat, in steam production, from exhaust, and from other process emissions. While these in some cases invite a general discussion across industry segments, some of the main emitting industries also have particular issues that needs to be addressed. We focus mainly on iron and steel, aluminum, fertilizer, refineries and cement to identify specific challenges, but also synergies between these (for example CCS infrastructure, hydrogen as a fuel);
- The time and speed of the transition: What is needed to succeed? Without considering the feasibility of the transition, what is needed in terms of contributions from the different geographical regions and from the different industry segment under different scenarios or the different shared socioeconomic pathways (SSPs)?
- Policy instruments to support the transition and local versus global participation: transition success requires cross-sectoral thinking, focusing on instigating society-wide change in a sustainable direction across Industries, dynamic constellations, but transformative action within them is constrained by path dependencies resulting from design, technological, investment, planning, and decisions. How should we proceed to succeed in the short run and towards 2050? What are the relative merits of regulatory and fiscal (taxes, cap-and-trade) approaches
- Climate finance, green industry and global trade: How can the deep decarbonization of industry and accelerated transition be supported by financial institutions? What about global competition and carbon leakage in scenarios where pollution is priced differently in different parts of the world. What role will border adjustments play? How can the transition be implemented in a fair way, both considering the further development of emerging economies and industrialized companies. How can stranded assets be minimized? How will the present heterogeneous Paris policy environment affect competitiveness, trade and the economy? What is the role of climate finance, international work sharing and technology licensing?
Confirmed speakers:
Nate Aden (WRI), Marie Bysveen (Sintef), Jae Edmonds (JGCRI), Sverre Gotaas (Herøya Industripark), Jonas Helseth (Bellona), Håvard Hellvik Kvadsheim (Equinor), Frode Leversund (Gassco), Thina Saltvedt (Nordea), Johnny Stuen (Oslo Kommune), Ivar Valstad (Hydro), Mariësse van Sluisveld (PBL), Lise Winther (Yara).
Date: 29 March
Time: 0830-1500
Registration: Press here
Place: Quality Hotel Augustin, Kongensgate 26, 7011 Trondheim
Contact: Håvard Tangvik